SMETA, amfori BSCI and SA8000 are three ways of checking how a factory treats its workers, and they are not interchangeable. SMETA is an audit method owned by Sedex that produces a report and a corrective action plan, with no pass or fail. An amfori BSCI audit ends in a rating from A to E. SA8000 is the only one of the three that is a certification. This explainer covers contract manufacturers of cosmetics and personal care products in any country. None of the three checks product quality, and none covers the farms and mines behind ingredients such as mica or palm derivatives. Ask a factory for the full report, the audit date and the open findings, not a logo.
Key takeaways
- Only SA8000 is a certificate. A factory can be “SA8000 certified”. It cannot be “SMETA certified” or “BSCI certified”, although many factory brochures say so. Those two produce an audit report, and the report can contain serious findings.
- The words on the brochure tell you an audit happened, not what it found. The useful information is the audit date, the audit type, the number and severity of findings, and how many are still open.
- A social audit covers one site on one or two days. It does not cover a second factory, a subcontracted filling line, or the ingredient supply chain. Mica, palm derivatives and shea need their own evidence. For palm, see RSPO Mass Balance and the other palm supply chain models explained.
- Retailers and laws are what turn this from optional into required. Large retailers often ask for a named scheme before listing a brand. Forced labour import rules in the US and, from 14 December 2027, the EU apply to products whatever the size of the brand.
- Your own ordering habits show up in the findings. Late artwork approval and compressed lead times before a holiday launch are a common cause of the excessive overtime that auditors record.
Who is this explainer for?
This article is for brand owners, sourcing managers and product developers who buy finished cosmetics from an OEM (original equipment manufacturer) or ODM (original design manufacturer) and have been asked, by a retailer, an investor or their own values, to show that the factory treats workers properly. It assumes you already know how to check product quality systems. If you do not, start with our checklist for auditing a cosmetics factory before you sign, then come back here for the labour side.
What is a social compliance audit, and how is it different from a GMP audit?
A social compliance audit is an inspection of working conditions at a production site: wages, working hours, contracts, recruitment, health and safety, and whether anyone is working under coercion or under age. It is carried out by a trained auditor, usually over one to four days, through a site tour, a review of payroll and time records, and confidential interviews with workers.
A GMP (good manufacturing practice) audit looks at a different thing entirely. It asks whether the product is made cleanly, consistently and traceably, usually against ISO 22716. Our guide to cosmetic GMP and ISO 22716 covers that side. A factory can hold a strong GMP certificate and still have unpaid overtime, and a factory with a clean social audit can still ship a contaminated batch. The two sets of evidence do not substitute for each other, and neither appears in the other’s report.
Most social audit schemes are built on the same foundations: the conventions of the International Labour Organization (ILO), local labour law, and a code of conduct. The code most often used in consumer goods is the Ethical Trading Initiative (ETI) Base Code, which has nine clauses, from “employment is freely chosen” to “no harsh or inhumane treatment is allowed”. Where the law and the code differ, auditors normally apply whichever gives the worker more protection.
What does SMETA mean?
SMETA stands for Sedex Members Ethical Trade Audit. It is an audit methodology published by Sedex, a membership organisation that runs an online platform where suppliers store audit reports and choose which customers can see them. SMETA is a method and a report format. It is not a standard a factory passes, and Sedex does not issue a certificate for it.
A SMETA audit comes in two sizes. The 2-pillar audit covers labour standards and health and safety, with a short environment section. The 4-pillar audit adds a fuller environment assessment and business ethics. A buyer who asks for “SMETA 4-pillar” is asking for the larger one, so check which version a factory actually holds before assuming it meets a retailer’s requirement.
The current version is SMETA 7.0, published by Sedex in September 2024. It breaks the ETI Base Code into specific workplace requirements, adds a review of the management systems behind each one, and introduces a finding type called “collaborative action required” for issues such as living wages and responsible recruitment that a factory cannot fix alone. The output is an audit report and a Corrective Action Plan Report (CAPR) listing each finding and the date by which it should be closed. Reports written under earlier versions grade findings by severity, with labels such as minor, major, critical and business critical.
What does amfori BSCI mean?
BSCI stands for Business Social Compliance Initiative. It is run by amfori, a business association based in Brussels whose members are mainly retailers, importers and brands. The members sign the amfori BSCI Code of Conduct and then monitor their producers against it. An audit is normally linked to an amfori member, so a factory usually enters the system because a customer brings it in.
The audit scores a site across 13 performance areas, including fair remuneration, decent working hours, occupational health and safety, no child labour, no bonded labour, protection of the environment and ethical business behaviour. Each area and the audit as a whole receive a letter: A (very good), B (good), C (acceptable), D (insufficient) or E (unacceptable). An A or B result is generally valid for two years. A C, D or E result calls for a follow-up audit within twelve months. Separately, a small set of “zero tolerance” findings, such as child labour, forced labour or an immediate danger to life, triggers an alert to the linked members straight away.
Like SMETA, amfori BSCI is not a certification. A factory that says it is “BSCI certified” is using shorthand. The accurate statement is “audited under amfori BSCI, overall rating B, on this date”, and that is the sentence you want in writing.
What does SA8000 mean?
SA8000 is a certifiable standard for decent work, published by Social Accountability International (SAI), a non-profit based in New York. It works like an ISO management system standard: an accredited certification body audits the site, issues a certificate, and returns for surveillance audits during the certificate cycle. Accreditation of those certification bodies is handled by Social Accountability Accreditation Services (SAAS), and SAI states that only certificates issued by SAAS-validated firms are recognised.
The standard is in transition. SAI has published SA8000:2026, which is organised around seven decent work principles and ten management system criteria. According to the SAI transition timeline (checked November 2026), certification audits of new clients move to the 2026 version from 1 January 2027, and remaining SA8000:2014 certificates are due to be withdrawn in mid-2029. During the overlap, ask a factory which version its certificate was issued against.
SA8000 is harder to obtain and maintain than a one-off audit, so fewer factories hold it. In cosmetics contract manufacturing it is far less common than SMETA or amfori BSCI. Where a factory does hold it, the certificate number and certification body can be checked against the list of certified organisations that SAAS publishes.
How do SMETA, amfori BSCI, SA8000 and EcoVadis compare?
The four names buyers meet most often differ in who owns them, what the output is, and how long that output stays current. EcoVadis is included because factories often present it alongside the others, although it is a different kind of evidence.
| Scheme | Owner | What it is | Output | How long it stays current | Where a buyer checks it | Best fit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SMETA | Sedex | Audit methodology, 2-pillar or 4-pillar | Audit report and corrective action plan; no pass or fail | No fixed validity; the customer sets the repeat cycle, commonly one to two years | Sedex platform, with the supplier granting access | Brands selling to grocery, pharmacy and department store chains that name SMETA |
| amfori BSCI | amfori | Member-driven audit against a code of conduct | Rating A to E across 13 performance areas | A or B generally two years; C, D or E follow-up within twelve months | amfori Sustainability Platform, through an amfori member | Brands supplying European retailers and importers that are amfori members |
| SA8000 | Social Accountability International | Certifiable management system standard | Certificate from a SAAS-accredited body | Multi-year certificate with surveillance audits during the cycle | SAAS list of certified organisations; the certificate itself | Buyers who want continuous oversight of a long-term, high-volume supplier |
| EcoVadis | EcoVadis | Sustainability rating from submitted documents | Scorecard out of 100 and a medal tier | Reassessed periodically, typically yearly | EcoVadis platform, with the supplier sharing the scorecard | Corporate procurement questionnaires; not a substitute for an on-site labour audit |
The practical reading is simple. If your customer names a scheme, that scheme is the answer and the others do not replace it. If nobody has named one, a recent SMETA 4-pillar or an amfori BSCI rating of A or B is the evidence most cosmetics factories can supply and most retailers will accept. For how these sit beside quality and product certificates, see our review of the key certifications of a quality cosmetics factory.
What does a social audit not tell you?
A social audit is a sample of one site at one time, and four limits follow from that.
- It is tied to an address. If the factory fills your product at a second site or sends part of the work to a subcontractor, the report does not cover it. This is one reason to know whether you are dealing with a manufacturer or an intermediary, which we cover in factory vs trading company vs sourcing agent.
- It stops at the factory gate. The mica in a highlighter, the palm-derived emulsifier in a lotion and the shea butter in a balm come from supply chains with their own labour risks. Evidence there comes from schemes such as the Responsible Mica Initiative and the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), and from the ingredient supplier’s own declarations.
- It depends on what the auditor was shown. Announced audits give a site time to prepare. Semi-announced and unannounced audits reduce that, which is why some retailers insist on them. Worker interviews are the strongest protection against prepared records, so a report with few interviews relative to headcount is weaker evidence.
- It says nothing about the product. No social audit checks formula, microbiology, stability or labelling.
Auditor quality matters too. The Association of Professional Social Compliance Auditors (APSCA) registers individual auditors and member firms. Asking whether the audit firm is an APSCA member and whether the lead auditor is APSCA-registered is a quick credibility check.
How do you read a social audit report from a cosmetics factory?
Read the summary page first for four facts: the site address, the audit date, the audit type (announced or not, 2-pillar or 4-pillar, full or follow-up), and the count of findings by severity. Then read the findings themselves. The table below lists the findings that appear most often at light-manufacturing sites such as filling and packing plants, what each usually points to, and the question to put to the factory.
| Finding in the report | What it usually indicates | How serious | What to ask the factory |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weekly hours above 60 in peak months | Capacity is sold beyond what one shift can deliver; seasonal orders are compressed | Common; serious if persistent or unpaid | Which months, how many workers, and what has changed in production planning since |
| Overtime not paid at the legal premium | Payroll error or deliberate underpayment | Serious; back pay is the normal remedy | Evidence that affected workers were repaid, with dates |
| Workers paid recruitment fees to an agent | Migrant or agency labour hired through paid brokers; a debt bondage risk | Serious; an ILO forced labour indicator | The recruitment policy, the agents used, and whether fees were reimbursed |
| Passports or identity documents held by the employer | Restriction of movement, even where described as safekeeping | Critical in most schemes | Proof that documents were returned and that workers have lockable storage |
| Blocked fire exit or missing evacuation drill | Weak day-to-day safety management | Serious but quick to fix | Photographs of the correction and the drill record |
| Flammable or hazardous materials stored without controls | Relevant to ethanol, fragrance, aerosol propellant and fine powders in cosmetics plants | Serious; can be an immediate danger finding | The storage layout, ventilation, and training records for the compounding area |
| Incomplete or inconsistent time and wage records | Poor record keeping, or records prepared for the audit | Serious; it undermines every other conclusion | Whether the follow-up audit verified hours against production records |
| No functioning grievance channel | Workers have no safe way to raise problems | Moderate; a management system gap | How complaints are received, who sees them, and one closed example |
The ILO indicators of forced labour list eleven warning signs, among them retention of identity documents, withholding of wages, debt bondage and excessive overtime. One indicator does not prove forced labour, but any of them in a report deserves a written answer before you place an order.
The working-hours finding is worth understanding in numbers. The ETI Base Code sets contracted hours at no more than 48 a week and total hours at no more than 60 in any seven-day period, with at least one day off in seven. A filling line running 11-hour shifts six days a week reaches 66 hours and breaches the limit by six hours per worker. A buyer who approves artwork three weeks late and still expects the original ship date is often the reason that schedule exists. If you plan seasonal products, the backward timeline in our guide to planning a holiday gift set shows how to keep that pressure off the line.
How recent does a social audit need to be?
There is no single rule, because SMETA has no fixed validity and each retailer sets its own. The decision table below is the working rule we suggest for a brand with no customer requirement yet. It is our editorial guidance, not a scheme rule.
| What the factory provides | Open findings | Suggested action |
|---|---|---|
| Full report dated within the last 12 months | None critical; others have closure dates | Accept, and diarise the next audit date |
| Full report dated within the last 12 months | One or more critical or zero tolerance findings | Ask for the follow-up audit or closure evidence before ordering |
| Full report 12 to 24 months old | Any | Ask for the corrective action status and the date of the next scheduled audit |
| Report older than 24 months, or an amfori BSCI C, D or E with no follow-up | Any | Treat as no current evidence; ask for a new audit |
| Summary page, logo or membership certificate only | Unknown | Ask for the full report; Sedex membership alone means no audit has necessarily taken place |
| Nothing, at a small or new factory | Unknown | Use a self-assessment questionnaire now and agree a date for a first audit in the supply agreement |
Why would a small beauty brand need a social audit at all?
A small brand needs social audit evidence for two reasons: customers ask for it, and import and due diligence laws increasingly assume it exists. The retailer route is the more immediate one. Chains that list private label and indie brands commonly ask for a named audit as part of supplier onboarding, alongside insurance and product documents. Our step-by-step guide to getting a private label brand into retail covers the rest of that pack.
The legal route is slower but wider. The table summarises four laws that reach cosmetics supply chains. Thresholds and dates were checked against the linked official texts in November 2026.
| Law | Jurisdiction | Who it binds directly | What it means for a small brand |
|---|---|---|---|
| Modern Slavery Act 2015, section 54 | United Kingdom | Commercial organisations supplying goods or services in the UK with turnover of £36 million or more | No direct duty, but large UK retailers pass questionnaires and audit requests down to suppliers |
| Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act | United States | Any importer, whatever its size | Goods made wholly or in part in Xinjiang, or by listed entities, are presumed to be made with forced labour and can be detained at the border |
| Regulation (EU) 2024/3015 on products made with forced labour | European Union | Any economic operator placing products on, or exporting from, the EU market | Applies from 14 December 2027; products can be withdrawn if forced labour is found at any stage of production |
| Directive (EU) 2024/1760 on corporate sustainability due diligence | European Union | Very large companies only | Indirect: large customers write supplier codes and audit rights into contracts. Scope and dates were revised under the EU’s 2025 simplification package, so check the current text |
Australia’s Modern Slavery Act 2018 follows the UK reporting model for entities with consolidated revenue of at least A$100 million. A social audit does not by itself satisfy any of these laws. It is one piece of evidence in a due diligence file, and for import rules the question regulators ask is about the origin of inputs as well as the final factory. Brands planning to sell across several of these markets can pair this with our guide to expanding into the EU, UK and US.
Who pays for a social audit, and how long does it take?
The factory normally pays, because one audit report can be shared with every customer. That is the logic of both the Sedex platform and the amfori platform: audit once, share many times. A brand usually pays only when it demands an extra audit, an unannounced audit, or a scheme the factory does not already hold.
Audit firms price by auditor day, and the number of days rises with headcount. A site with under 100 workers is typically a one-day audit for the two core pillars, with more time for a 4-pillar scope, and a site with several hundred workers runs to two or three days. Fees vary by country and firm and should be quoted, not assumed. Allow four to eight weeks from booking to a final report, and longer in the months before major retail seasons when audit firms are busy.
The larger cost is corrective action. Back pay for underpaid overtime, reimbursement of recruitment fees, an extra shift to bring hours down, or fire safety works can cost far more than the audit. This is why a factory with no audit history is a different risk from a factory with an audit that found problems and fixed them. The second has already paid that cost.
How do you use social audits when choosing a manufacturer?
- Find out what your customers require. Ask each retailer or distributor which scheme, which scope and what maximum report age they accept. Do this before shortlisting factories.
- Ask at the first enquiry. Add one line to your request for quotation: which social audits the production site holds, the date, and the result. Add the report to the list in our checklist of documents to request from a cosmetics manufacturer.
- Match the address. The site on the audit report must be the site that will compound and fill your product. Check it against the business licence and the GMP certificate.
- Get the full report through the platform. Ask the factory to grant you visibility on Sedex or, if you or your customer is an amfori member, on the amfori platform. A PDF sent by email is acceptable for a first read but is easier to edit.
- Read the open findings and ask for evidence. For each open item, ask for the closure date and proof. Judge the response as much as the finding.
- Write it into the agreement. Include your code of conduct, a duty to keep a current audit, notice of any subcontracting, and a right to see future reports. Our examples of OEM cosmetics contract clauses show where such terms sit.
- Review your own behaviour once a year. Compare the forecasts you gave with the orders you placed, and count the rush orders. Persistent overtime findings at a factory you buy heavily from are partly your finding.
If you are still building a shortlist, the OEM Hallmark manufacturer directory lists factories by country and category. Use it to build the list, then ask each candidate the audit questions below before you request samples.
What questions should you ask a factory about its social audit?
- Which scheme, which scope, and was the audit announced, semi-announced or unannounced?
- Which audit firm carried it out, and is the lead auditor APSCA-registered?
- How many findings were raised, how many are closed, and what are the dates for the rest?
- Does the audited site carry out every stage of my order, or is any step subcontracted?
- Do you employ migrant or agency workers, and who pays the recruitment costs?
What mistakes do buyers make with social audits?
- Accepting “certified” at face value. For SMETA and amfori BSCI the word is wrong, and it hides the result. Ask for the rating or the findings.
- Treating Sedex membership as an audit. A supplier can join Sedex and complete a self-assessment questionnaire without ever being audited.
- Rejecting any factory with findings. Almost every audit has findings. A report with none at a busy site is not automatically better evidence than a report with six that were closed on time.
- Ignoring the address. A group may hold a good audit at its flagship plant and make your product somewhere else.
- Making ethical claims from an audit. A social audit does not support “ethically made” on a carton without further evidence. Our article on what OEM buyers must prove for clean and sustainable claims explains the standard of proof.
- Stopping at the factory. For colour cosmetics with mica and for formulas heavy in palm derivatives, the larger labour risk sits upstream of the audited site.
Frequently asked questions
Is SMETA a certification?
No. SMETA is an audit methodology owned by Sedex. It produces an audit report and a corrective action plan, and there is no pass, fail or certificate. A factory that describes itself as SMETA certified has been audited using SMETA, and the result could be anything from no findings to several critical ones. Ask for the full report and the date.
What is the difference between Sedex and SMETA?
Sedex is the organisation and the online platform. SMETA is the audit method Sedex publishes. A supplier can be a Sedex member, with a completed self-assessment questionnaire on the platform, without having had a SMETA audit. When a factory says it is “Sedex registered”, ask whether a SMETA audit has been uploaded and when it took place.
Is an amfori BSCI rating of C acceptable?
It depends on your customer. amfori describes C as acceptable, but it still calls for a follow-up audit within twelve months, and some retailers set their own minimum of A or B. If a factory holds a C, ask which performance areas pulled the rating down and for the remediation plan. A C in working hours during peak season is a different problem from a C in health and safety.
Can a small cosmetics factory get a social audit?
Yes. SMETA can be commissioned by any site through an approved audit firm, and a site with fewer than 100 workers is usually a short audit. amfori BSCI normally requires a link to an amfori member, so a small factory with no such customer tends to choose SMETA. If a factory has no audit, a self-assessment questionnaire and a dated commitment to a first audit is a reasonable interim step.
Does a social audit cover the ingredients in my product?
No. The audit covers the site where your product is compounded, filled and packed. It does not reach the mines, farms and processors that supply raw materials. For mica, palm derivatives and similar ingredients, ask the manufacturer for its raw material suppliers’ declarations and any scheme membership, such as RSPO supply chain certification or Responsible Mica Initiative participation.
Do I need a social audit to sell cosmetics in the EU or the US?
No law requires a brand to hold a social audit report. What the US already enforces, and the EU will from 14 December 2027, is a ban on products made with forced labour, applied to importers and operators of any size. A current social audit of your factory is one useful piece of evidence if a shipment is questioned, alongside records of where the inputs came from.
Sources
- Sedex, SMETA audit: methodology owner; 2-pillar and 4-pillar scope; SMETA 7.0.
- amfori, amfori BSCI: code of conduct, 13 performance areas and A to E rating.
- Social Accountability International, SA8000 Standard and certification programme timeline: SA8000:2026 structure and transition dates, checked November 2026.
- Ethical Trading Initiative, ETI Base Code: nine clauses; clause 6 working hours limits, checked November 2026.
- International Labour Organization, ILO indicators of forced labour.
- UK Modern Slavery Act 2015, section 54; US Customs and Border Protection, UFLPA; Regulation (EU) 2024/3015; Directive (EU) 2024/1760.
- APSCA, Responsible Mica Initiative and RSPO: auditor registration and ingredient-level schemes.
Limitations
This explainer describes how the schemes work in general and does not assess any individual factory. We did not audit factories for this article. Scheme rules change: amfori BSCI rating validity, SMETA finding categories and the SA8000:2026 transition dates should be confirmed with the scheme owner or your audit firm before you rely on them in a contract. Audit duration and timing figures are typical ranges, not quotations. The summaries of UK, US, EU and Australian law are simplified and are not legal advice; the EU due diligence directive in particular was still being amended when this was written. Take advice for your own products and markets.
